As debates over Makoko resurface, competing narratives are blurring the line between genuine concern and misleading claims, complicating efforts at sustainable urban development
The Makoko issue has once again taken centre stage in Lagos, drawing intense reactions from the public as debates over the demolition resurface. Competing narratives are blurring the line between genuine concern and misleading claims, complicating efforts at sustainable urban development.
Understandably, any discussion around demolition in such a densely populated, low-income community like Makoko in Lagos evokes strong emotions. However, the speed with which outrage has spread suggests that perception may be outpacing verified facts.
Across media channels, the Lagos State Government has been tagged as acting out of self-interest rather than public good, with claims of a hidden land acquisition agenda dominating conversations. This framing, while compelling, risks oversimplifying a complex urban challenge that demands both empathy and structural reform.
This concern was brought to the fore and adorned some sculpted options during a programme aired on national television, where one of the residents, a septuagenarian, was accompanied by some NGO representatives. That portrayal, while emotionally compelling, one must say, risks distorting a far more complex reality.
However, considering the inciteful effect that was subtly packaged in the position and tone of the discussion, it is therefore necessary to set the record straight and address the growing wave of narratives that, intentionally or otherwise, misrepresent both the intent and substance of government policy. At the centre of this conversation is a broader and more delicate issue: the role of activism in shaping public perception. Civil society engagement is vital in any democracy, particularly when it comes to protecting vulnerable communities like Makoko.
However, activism must be exercised with a sense of responsibility that matches its influence, walking with caution and mindful of the nuances of the environmental reality.
Thus, when advocacy evolves into agitation that dismisses nuance, amplifies distrust and frames every state intervention as predatory, it begins to do a disservice to the very people it claims to defend, and more importantly its brand, albeit with fleeting glory.
In environments as sensitive as Makoko, such narratives can inflame tensions, harden positions and complicate efforts geared at constructive engagement. Observably, there is an increasing tendency among certain actors to reduce complex urban policy decisions into shallow and oversimplified binaries of “the people versus the government.”
This framing may generate attention and even sympathy, but it certainly obscures the difficult truths that the public ought not to shy away from
Lagos is not a static entity; it is one of Africa’s fastest-growing urban centres, and its sustainability depends on deliberate planning, regulation and, at times, difficult transitions fused into hard choices.
To suggest that every attempt at restructuring informal settlements is an act of dispossession is to ignore both historical precedents and present-day realities.
Makoko itself is a product of decades of organic growth outside formal urban planning frameworks. What started as a modest fishing settlement has evolved into a densely populated waterfront community, defined as much by its resilience as by its infrastructure deficiencies.
Beneath the iconic imagery of stilt houses and canoes lies a precarious living environment marked by overcrowding, high crime rate, poor sanitation, environmental degradation and heightened vulnerability to fire outbreaks and flooding.
These are not theoretical concerns; they are live experiences that pose real and immediate risks. The Lagos State Government’s engagement with Makoko must be understood within the context of its broader ambition to position Lagos as a 21st-century megacity capable of supporting its rapidly expanding population.
Urban renewal, in this regard, is not about aesthetics or elite preference; it is about safety, functionality, and the long-term viability of the city, without consciously leaving any of its part behind. Settlements like Makoko, built without regard to structural integrity, approval of any sort, environmental impact, or access to essential services cannot be sustained indefinitely without consequences.
Relocation, therefore, emerges not as an arbitrary policy choice but as part of a continuum of urban management strategies aimed at improving living conditions and reducing systemic risks.
Sadly, the proposal to move residents to areas such as Agbowa has been met with resistance, particularly on the grounds that Makoko’s inhabitants, many of whom are fishermen, require proximity to water for their livelihoods. This concern is legitimate, but it is not insurmountable.
Agbowa and its surrounding areas exist within a broader coastal and riverine ecosystem, and with proper planning, infrastructure can be developed to support fishing and related economic activities. The question is not whether alternatives exist, but whether there is sufficient willingness to explore and refine them collaboratively. It is also important to note that Lagos is not without precedent in managing such transitions.
The relocation of sawmill operators from Oko Baba- Lagos, a community very close to Makoko stands as a case in point. Initially met with scepticism and resistance, the exercise ultimately resulted in the allocation of structured workspaces and improved living conditions for the affected individuals. While no relocation process is without its challenges, the Oko Baba experience demonstrates that, when properly executed, such initiatives can yield tangible benefits for both the people and the city at large.
Equally instructive are redevelopment efforts in other parts of the state, including areas within Agboyi-Ketu, where interventions by the Ministry of Physical Planning and Urban Development have transformed previously disorganised settlements into more regulated and habitable environments. These examples underscore a consistent policy direction: the gradual replacement of hazardous, unplanned communities with safer, more sustainable alternatives.
To insist, as some have done, particularly non-governmental organisations that seem to be profiting from the mess and pretending to be fighting for the people, that Makoko must remain untouched in its current form is to romanticise a condition that is, in reality, fraught with risk and fraud combined.
Agreeably, preservation of culture and livelihood is important, but it must be balanced against the imperative of ensuring safety, dignity and access to basic services.
No responsible government can ignore the warning signs inherent in settlements that lack the most fundamental basic infrastructure. None of these absolves the state of its responsibility to act with transparency, empathy, and inclusivity. Engagement with affected communities must be genuine and relocation plans must be accompanied by clear guarantees regarding housing, livelihoods and social services. Trust is not demanded; it is built through consistent and demonstrable action.
However, it is equally incumbent on those who occupy the advocacy space to ensure that their interventions are guided by facts rather than sentiment and by long-term outcomes rather than immediate optics.
Activism needs to be reminded that public discourse must rise above the temptation to assign motives without evidence or to weaponise the anxieties of vulnerable populations for selfish agendas. The Makoko debate is, ultimately, a reflection of the growing pains of a city in transition. It is a test of Lagos’ ability to balance compassion with pragmatism, and of society’s capacity to engage in honest and constructive dialogue.
Misleading impressions, no matter how well presented, do little to advance this cause. What is required, particularly of activism, instead, is a shared commitment to truth, responsibility and the collective good. In clarifying the issues surrounding Makoko, the goal is not to silence dissent but to ensure that it is informed, measured, and aligned with the realities on ground.
Only then can Lagos move forward in a manner that truly serves all its residents, both present and future.
About the author
Rwanda vs Nigeria: Chelle reignites the Super Eagles’ aspirations for the 2026 World Cup in Kigali.
On Friday, Eric Chelle became the inaugural non-Nigerian African coach to take the helm of the Super Eagles. The Malian coach directed his first match, resulting in a 2-0 win against Rwanda during a qualifying round for the 2026 World Cup. Chelle's appointment by the Nigeria Football Federation (NFF) took place on January 7, as he replaced Finidi George and succeeded interim coach Augustine Eguavoen. Since that time, he has dedicated three months to traveling across Nigeria, observing domestic league matches, and engaging with his players based in Europe. However, his initial team selection remained perplexing. Chelle opted for a highly offensive formation in Kigali, which appeared unbalanced on paper. Victor Osimhen, Samuel Chukwueze, Ademola Lookman, and Moses Simon were all included in the attacking lineup, while Alex Iwobi and Wilfred Ndidi occupied the midfield positions. "I had mixed feelings. […]
Plateau killings: IGP, COAS deploy more troops, vow justice
Concerned Nigerians condemn the attack The Inspector-General of Police (IGP) Olatunji Disu has said a sizeable number of suspects linked to the Palm Sunday killings in Angwan Rukuba and nearby communities in Jos, Plateau State, were already in custody, vowing that all the culprits at at large would be fished out.He revealed this during his condolence visit to Jos, yesterday, where he said additional security deployments have been made to bring the situation under control.At least 27 persons were killed and 19 others were seriously injured in the attack that has continued to generat public outcry. Disu, who visited the affected areas, hospitalised victims and met Governor Caleb Mutfwang at Government House, said one of those arrested impersonated a soldier.The IGP said: “This is a very sad incident, and we have been doing everything in our powers to ensure that […]
Alleged coup plotters: Families protest at National Assembly
The families of the detained officers accused of a coup attempt against President Bola Ahmed Tinubu yesterday protested at the National Assembly. They called for justice to be done openly in the matter in accordance with the law.The protesters included the spouses of the detained military officers, as well as their children and other relatives. Carrying placards with various inscriptions, they expressed frustration that their loved ones have been held for too long without due process.The distraught families said they faced emotional and financial hardship since the officers were detained.The wife of one of the detainees, who gave her name simply as Nana, said they were calling for fairness in their trial. “We are here to plead with the government to please charge our husbands to court. We are not saying they should just be released like that. Necessary action […]
Fraud Case: El-Rufai taken back to custody
Operatives of the Independent Corrupt Practices and Other Related Offences Commission (ICPC) yesterday returned former Kaduna State Governor Mallam Nasir El-Rufai to their custody after the resumed hearing of his bail application at the Federal High Court in Kaduna.The court adjourned hearing of the bail application filed by former Kaduna State Governor till today. His counsel, Ubong Akpan (SAN), who declined detailed comments on the proceedings, confirmed the development shortly after yesterday’s court session."I’m sorry, I can’t talk now, we are in the middle of work. I have to go and file responses. The hearing of the bail application has been adjourned till tomorrow,” Ubong Akpan said. The former governor was subsequently taken away from the court premises by ICPC operatives in a white Hilux vehicle.He had returned to the Federal High Court amid tight security for the hearing of […]
Plateau killings and the curfew
The fresh wave of violence in Plateau State has once again exposed a painful reality. Nigeria is not just dealing with isolated attacks, but a deep-rooted and persistent security crisis. On Sunday, March 29, gunmen stormed the Gari Ya Waye area of Angwan Rukuba in Jos North, killing at least 20 people, with some reports placing the death toll closer to 30. Witnesses disclosed to Ayemafuge while recounting a chilling pattern: "attackers arriving on motorcycles in the evening, opening fire indiscriminately on defenceless residents. This is not an isolated incident; it is part of a recurring cycle of violence in the region.In response, authorities imposed a 48-hour curfew, yet another predictable government reaction that has, over time, become more symbolic than effective. From Kaduna State to Zamfara State, and even parts of Borno State during the height of insurgency, curfews […]
Resign now: Ondo Govt directs political appointees eyeing 2027 elections to resign by March 31
The Ondo state government has directed all political appointees planning to run in the 2027 general elections to resign by March 31, 2026.This is contained in an advisory directive issued by the state Attorney-General and Commissioner for Justice, Dr Kayode Ajulo, SAN. The directive cited by Ayemafuge on Tuesday was titled "Advisory Directive on Resignation Requirements for Civil Servants and Political Appointees in Ondo State Intending to Contest the 2027 General Elections.”“It is strongly advised that all political appointees intending to contest the 2027 General Elections submit their formal letters of resignation on or before 31st March 2026, through the Office of the Secretary to the State Government,” the Advisory said.According to it, the purpose of the “Directive” is to ensure legal clarity, promote transparency, uphold the neutrality and integrity of the public service, and prevent avoidable disqualification or electoral […]
Aiyedatiwa sacks all SSAs, SAs
The Governor of Ondo State, Dr Lucky Aiyedatiwa, has sacked all Senior Special Assistants(SSAs) and Special Assistants(SAs) in his administration with immediate effect. This is contained in a statement made available to Ayemafuge on Monday in Akure by the Chief Press Secretary to the Governor, Mr Ebenezer Adeniyan.According to Adeniyan, the step is part of efforts to enhance efficiency and service delivery in the state.He expressed appreciation to the affected aides for their contributions to the development of the state and wished them success in their future endeavours. Adeniyan disclosed that the governor would appoint about 1,000 new aides drawn from the 203 wards across the 18 local government areas of the state.He added that the move was aimed at strengthening coordination and injecting fresh capacity into the administration. Ayemafuge gathered that the move was part of the realignment towards […]
Related
Plateau killings: IGP, COAS deploy more troops, vow justice
Concerned Nigerians condemn the attack The Inspector-General of Police (IGP) Olatunji Disu has said a sizeable number of suspects linked to the Palm Sunday killings in Angwan Rukuba and nearby communities in Jos, Plateau State, were already in custody, vowing that all the culprits at at large would be fished out.He revealed this during his condolence visit to Jos, yesterday, where he said additional security deployments have been made to bring the situation under control.At least 27 persons were killed and 19 others were seriously injured in the attack that has continued to generat public outcry. Disu, who visited the affected areas, hospitalised victims and met Governor Caleb Mutfwang at Government House, said one of those arrested impersonated a soldier.The IGP said: “This is a very sad incident, and we have been doing everything in our powers to ensure that […]
Alleged coup plotters: Families protest at National Assembly
The families of the detained officers accused of a coup attempt against President Bola Ahmed Tinubu yesterday protested at the National Assembly. They called for justice to be done openly in the matter in accordance with the law.The protesters included the spouses of the detained military officers, as well as their children and other relatives. Carrying placards with various inscriptions, they expressed frustration that their loved ones have been held for too long without due process.The distraught families said they faced emotional and financial hardship since the officers were detained.The wife of one of the detainees, who gave her name simply as Nana, said they were calling for fairness in their trial. “We are here to plead with the government to please charge our husbands to court. We are not saying they should just be released like that. Necessary action […]
Fraud Case: El-Rufai taken back to custody
Operatives of the Independent Corrupt Practices and Other Related Offences Commission (ICPC) yesterday returned former Kaduna State Governor Mallam Nasir El-Rufai to their custody after the resumed hearing of his bail application at the Federal High Court in Kaduna.The court adjourned hearing of the bail application filed by former Kaduna State Governor till today. His counsel, Ubong Akpan (SAN), who declined detailed comments on the proceedings, confirmed the development shortly after yesterday’s court session."I’m sorry, I can’t talk now, we are in the middle of work. I have to go and file responses. The hearing of the bail application has been adjourned till tomorrow,” Ubong Akpan said. The former governor was subsequently taken away from the court premises by ICPC operatives in a white Hilux vehicle.He had returned to the Federal High Court amid tight security for the hearing of […]
Plateau killings and the curfew
The fresh wave of violence in Plateau State has once again exposed a painful reality. Nigeria is not just dealing with isolated attacks, but a deep-rooted and persistent security crisis. On Sunday, March 29, gunmen stormed the Gari Ya Waye area of Angwan Rukuba in Jos North, killing at least 20 people, with some reports placing the death toll closer to 30. Witnesses disclosed to Ayemafuge while recounting a chilling pattern: "attackers arriving on motorcycles in the evening, opening fire indiscriminately on defenceless residents. This is not an isolated incident; it is part of a recurring cycle of violence in the region.In response, authorities imposed a 48-hour curfew, yet another predictable government reaction that has, over time, become more symbolic than effective. From Kaduna State to Zamfara State, and even parts of Borno State during the height of insurgency, curfews […]
Resign now: Ondo Govt directs political appointees eyeing 2027 elections to resign by March 31
The Ondo state government has directed all political appointees planning to run in the 2027 general elections to resign by March 31, 2026.This is contained in an advisory directive issued by the state Attorney-General and Commissioner for Justice, Dr Kayode Ajulo, SAN. The directive cited by Ayemafuge on Tuesday was titled "Advisory Directive on Resignation Requirements for Civil Servants and Political Appointees in Ondo State Intending to Contest the 2027 General Elections.”“It is strongly advised that all political appointees intending to contest the 2027 General Elections submit their formal letters of resignation on or before 31st March 2026, through the Office of the Secretary to the State Government,” the Advisory said.According to it, the purpose of the “Directive” is to ensure legal clarity, promote transparency, uphold the neutrality and integrity of the public service, and prevent avoidable disqualification or electoral […]
Aiyedatiwa sacks all SSAs, SAs
The Governor of Ondo State, Dr Lucky Aiyedatiwa, has sacked all Senior Special Assistants(SSAs) and Special Assistants(SAs) in his administration with immediate effect. This is contained in a statement made available to Ayemafuge on Monday in Akure by the Chief Press Secretary to the Governor, Mr Ebenezer Adeniyan.According to Adeniyan, the step is part of efforts to enhance efficiency and service delivery in the state.He expressed appreciation to the affected aides for their contributions to the development of the state and wished them success in their future endeavours. Adeniyan disclosed that the governor would appoint about 1,000 new aides drawn from the 203 wards across the 18 local government areas of the state.He added that the move was aimed at strengthening coordination and injecting fresh capacity into the administration. Ayemafuge gathered that the move was part of the realignment towards […]
Be the first to leave a comment