As debates over Makoko resurface, competing narratives are blurring the line between genuine concern and misleading claims, complicating efforts at sustainable urban development
The Makoko issue has once again taken centre stage in Lagos, drawing intense reactions from the public as debates over the demolition resurface. Competing narratives are blurring the line between genuine concern and misleading claims, complicating efforts at sustainable urban development.
Understandably, any discussion around demolition in such a densely populated, low-income community like Makoko in Lagos evokes strong emotions. However, the speed with which outrage has spread suggests that perception may be outpacing verified facts.
Across media channels, the Lagos State Government has been tagged as acting out of self-interest rather than public good, with claims of a hidden land acquisition agenda dominating conversations. This framing, while compelling, risks oversimplifying a complex urban challenge that demands both empathy and structural reform.
This concern was brought to the fore and adorned some sculpted options during a programme aired on national television, where one of the residents, a septuagenarian, was accompanied by some NGO representatives. That portrayal, while emotionally compelling, one must say, risks distorting a far more complex reality.
However, considering the inciteful effect that was subtly packaged in the position and tone of the discussion, it is therefore necessary to set the record straight and address the growing wave of narratives that, intentionally or otherwise, misrepresent both the intent and substance of government policy. At the centre of this conversation is a broader and more delicate issue: the role of activism in shaping public perception. Civil society engagement is vital in any democracy, particularly when it comes to protecting vulnerable communities like Makoko.
However, activism must be exercised with a sense of responsibility that matches its influence, walking with caution and mindful of the nuances of the environmental reality.
Thus, when advocacy evolves into agitation that dismisses nuance, amplifies distrust and frames every state intervention as predatory, it begins to do a disservice to the very people it claims to defend, and more importantly its brand, albeit with fleeting glory.
In environments as sensitive as Makoko, such narratives can inflame tensions, harden positions and complicate efforts geared at constructive engagement. Observably, there is an increasing tendency among certain actors to reduce complex urban policy decisions into shallow and oversimplified binaries of “the people versus the government.”
This framing may generate attention and even sympathy, but it certainly obscures the difficult truths that the public ought not to shy away from
Lagos is not a static entity; it is one of Africa’s fastest-growing urban centres, and its sustainability depends on deliberate planning, regulation and, at times, difficult transitions fused into hard choices.
To suggest that every attempt at restructuring informal settlements is an act of dispossession is to ignore both historical precedents and present-day realities.
Makoko itself is a product of decades of organic growth outside formal urban planning frameworks. What started as a modest fishing settlement has evolved into a densely populated waterfront community, defined as much by its resilience as by its infrastructure deficiencies.
Beneath the iconic imagery of stilt houses and canoes lies a precarious living environment marked by overcrowding, high crime rate, poor sanitation, environmental degradation and heightened vulnerability to fire outbreaks and flooding.
These are not theoretical concerns; they are live experiences that pose real and immediate risks. The Lagos State Government’s engagement with Makoko must be understood within the context of its broader ambition to position Lagos as a 21st-century megacity capable of supporting its rapidly expanding population.
Urban renewal, in this regard, is not about aesthetics or elite preference; it is about safety, functionality, and the long-term viability of the city, without consciously leaving any of its part behind. Settlements like Makoko, built without regard to structural integrity, approval of any sort, environmental impact, or access to essential services cannot be sustained indefinitely without consequences.
Relocation, therefore, emerges not as an arbitrary policy choice but as part of a continuum of urban management strategies aimed at improving living conditions and reducing systemic risks.
Sadly, the proposal to move residents to areas such as Agbowa has been met with resistance, particularly on the grounds that Makoko’s inhabitants, many of whom are fishermen, require proximity to water for their livelihoods. This concern is legitimate, but it is not insurmountable.
Agbowa and its surrounding areas exist within a broader coastal and riverine ecosystem, and with proper planning, infrastructure can be developed to support fishing and related economic activities. The question is not whether alternatives exist, but whether there is sufficient willingness to explore and refine them collaboratively. It is also important to note that Lagos is not without precedent in managing such transitions.
The relocation of sawmill operators from Oko Baba- Lagos, a community very close to Makoko stands as a case in point. Initially met with scepticism and resistance, the exercise ultimately resulted in the allocation of structured workspaces and improved living conditions for the affected individuals. While no relocation process is without its challenges, the Oko Baba experience demonstrates that, when properly executed, such initiatives can yield tangible benefits for both the people and the city at large.
Equally instructive are redevelopment efforts in other parts of the state, including areas within Agboyi-Ketu, where interventions by the Ministry of Physical Planning and Urban Development have transformed previously disorganised settlements into more regulated and habitable environments. These examples underscore a consistent policy direction: the gradual replacement of hazardous, unplanned communities with safer, more sustainable alternatives.
To insist, as some have done, particularly non-governmental organisations that seem to be profiting from the mess and pretending to be fighting for the people, that Makoko must remain untouched in its current form is to romanticise a condition that is, in reality, fraught with risk and fraud combined.
Agreeably, preservation of culture and livelihood is important, but it must be balanced against the imperative of ensuring safety, dignity and access to basic services.
No responsible government can ignore the warning signs inherent in settlements that lack the most fundamental basic infrastructure. None of these absolves the state of its responsibility to act with transparency, empathy, and inclusivity. Engagement with affected communities must be genuine and relocation plans must be accompanied by clear guarantees regarding housing, livelihoods and social services. Trust is not demanded; it is built through consistent and demonstrable action.
However, it is equally incumbent on those who occupy the advocacy space to ensure that their interventions are guided by facts rather than sentiment and by long-term outcomes rather than immediate optics.
Activism needs to be reminded that public discourse must rise above the temptation to assign motives without evidence or to weaponise the anxieties of vulnerable populations for selfish agendas. The Makoko debate is, ultimately, a reflection of the growing pains of a city in transition. It is a test of Lagos’ ability to balance compassion with pragmatism, and of society’s capacity to engage in honest and constructive dialogue.
Misleading impressions, no matter how well presented, do little to advance this cause. What is required, particularly of activism, instead, is a shared commitment to truth, responsibility and the collective good. In clarifying the issues surrounding Makoko, the goal is not to silence dissent but to ensure that it is informed, measured, and aligned with the realities on ground.
Only then can Lagos move forward in a manner that truly serves all its residents, both present and future.
About the author
Rwanda vs Nigeria: Chelle reignites the Super Eagles’ aspirations for the 2026 World Cup in Kigali.
On Friday, Eric Chelle became the inaugural non-Nigerian African coach to take the helm of the Super Eagles. The Malian coach directed his first match, resulting in a 2-0 win against Rwanda during a qualifying round for the 2026 World Cup. Chelle's appointment by the Nigeria Football Federation (NFF) took place on January 7, as he replaced Finidi George and succeeded interim coach Augustine Eguavoen. Since that time, he has dedicated three months to traveling across Nigeria, observing domestic league matches, and engaging with his players based in Europe. However, his initial team selection remained perplexing. Chelle opted for a highly offensive formation in Kigali, which appeared unbalanced on paper. Victor Osimhen, Samuel Chukwueze, Ademola Lookman, and Moses Simon were all included in the attacking lineup, while Alex Iwobi and Wilfred Ndidi occupied the midfield positions. "I had mixed feelings. […]
Tragedy: Former deputy governor loses two children in accident
The immediate past Deputy Governor of Bauchi State, Senator Baba Tela, has lost two of his children, Mustapha and Ummi, in a fatal road accident. Our correspondent in Bauchi reported that the siblings reportedly died on Saturday after the vehicle conveying them was involved in a crash with a long vehicle (Trailer) on the Bauchi–Azare highway while they were returning to Bauchi from Azare, the headquarters of Katagum Local Government Area.They were said to have died on the spot of the accident due to the severity of the impact. Their bodies were later taken to a hospital in Bauchi, where medical personnel confirmed their deaths.Reacting to the tragedy, Bauchi State Governor, Bala Mohammed, described it as heartbreaking, and extended his condolences to Tela and his family. Mohammed, in a statement issued by his Special Adviser on Media and Publicity, Mukhtar […]
World Cup: Morocco defeats co-host Canada 3-0 to secure a spot in quarter-finals
The Atlas Lions of Morocco on Saturday defeated Canada 3-0 to secure a spot in the World Cup’s quarterfinals. The loss ends a historic run for World Cup co-host Canada, which won its first-ever knockout round with a 1-0 victory over South Africa to reach Saturday’s match. Morocco’s Azzedine Ounahi opened the scoring in the 50th minute of the game, giving the fans relief after a very confusing first half that left Moroccans almost depressed.Ounahi also scored a second goal for Morocco in the 82nd minute. Soufiane Rahimi ended the game with a third match in the added time. Exhaustion, as well as pressure from the Canadian team, which had been aggressively attempting to create shocks but not convert its chances.The Moroccan team, however, stood strong and balanced despite the showering of yellow cards by the British match official and […]
Court remands Sowore in Kuje Prison, dismisses recusal request
A Federal High Court in Abuja on Monday remanded the Presidential Candidate of the African Action Congress (AAC), Omoyele Sowore, at the Kuje Correctional Centre pending the determination of an application seeking a stay of execution of an earlier court order revoking his bail. The trial judge, Justice Mohammed Umar, also dismissed an application by Sowore seeking his recusal from the case over allegations of bias.In a brief ruling, Justice Umar directed that the defendant remain in custody pending the hearing and determination of a motion for stay of execution filed by his new counsel, Adeyinka Olumide-Fusika SAN. The court subsequently adjourned the matter until June 24 for hearing of the application. trending_flat News & Politics Court remands Sowore in Kuje Prison, dismisses recusal request Arthur Iyamore June 22, 2026 trending_flat News Bandit Leader Claims Responsibility for Attacks, Expresses Interest […]
Heavy military casualties in Niger Republic as attacks claim 265 security personnel
No fewer than 265 members of Niger’s Defence and Security Forces (FDS), including senior officers, have reportedly been killed in a series of coordinated attacks across different parts of the country between June 17 and June 19. Our correspondent in Niger Republic reported that according to security sources, one of the deadliest incidents occurred in Inates, where 101 soldiers were reported killed during an attack attributed to fighters of the Islamic State in the Sahel. The Zagazola Makama quoted sources as saying that 52 of the victims had been buried in the Tillabéri Region, while 49 other soldiers who were initially declared missing had subsequently been presumed dead. They added that 20 soldiers were reportedly taken captive during the attack. The security sources further disclosed that the attacks formed part of a broader wave of violence that targeted several military […]
Dangote meets Aiyedatiwa, plans biggest free trade zone in Ondo
The President of Dangote Group, Alhaji Aliko Dangote, has reaffirmed plans to develop a large-scale industrial and free trade zone at Olokola in Ilaje Local Government Area of Ondo State. He described the development as a power-driven investment hub designed to attract manufacturers and reduce infrastructure constraints for investors.Dangote stated this on Monday during a visit to Governor Lucky Aiyedatiwa at his office in Akure, the state capital. According to him, the renewed investment framework covers power generation, cement production, gas infrastructure and industrial manufacturing.He said the proposed Olokola project would go beyond a conventional free trade zone, explaining that it would be fully equipped with power, water and logistics infrastructure to enable investors to operate without delays associated with basic utilities.“We want to create the biggest free trade zone where investors can just come and plug in. We will […]
Lagos Deputy Commissioner of Police is dead
The Deputy Commissioner of Police in charge of Finance and Administration, Lagos State Police Command, DCP Khan Salihu is dead. The command’s spokesperson, SP Ambimbola Adebisi disclosed this in a statement.According to the statement, the DCP passed away on Monday, June 15, 2026. Ambimbola described the deceased as a “highly dedicated, disciplined, and committed senior police officer who served the Nigeria Police Force with exceptional professionalism, loyalty, and integrity”. “Throughout his distinguished career, DCP Khan Salihu exemplified diligence, exemplary leadership, and an unwavering commitment to duty. trending_flat News & Politics Lagos Deputy Commissioner of Police is dead Arthur Iyamore June 16, 2026 trending_flat Inside Ondo Teenager Arrested After Alleged Bottle Attack on Boyfriend in Ondo Tosin June 16, 2026 trending_flat Business Dangote Plans Nigeria’s Largest Industrial Zone in Ondo Tosin June 16, 2026 trending_flat Business Ondo Sets Up Committee to […]
Related
Kogi APC chairman shot dead
Gunmen suspected to be bandits have killed Ishaq Yunusa, the Chairman of the All Progressives Congress(APC) in Dekina Local Government Area of Kogi State. The incident occurred on the Itobe–Ochadamu Expressway in Ofu Local Government Area of the state at about 5.00p.m on Thursday. Confirming the killing in a statement on Friday, the spokesperson for the Police Command in Kogi State, ASP Saliu Afusat, said the command had launched an investigation into the incident. The police explained that the incident occurred around Ojuwo Olijo when armed assailants emerged from the surrounding bush and shot indiscriminately at motorists. The command further said that a blue Toyota Corolla was later found abandoned along the highway, with the driver, identified as Ishaq Yunusa, found dead inside the vehicle. The police disclosed that another occupant of the vehicle was taken into the bush […]
ATIKU CONFUSED ON PETROL SUBSIDY
* THIRD U-TURN IN ONE WEEK SHOWS HE IS SIMPLY PLAYING POLITICS The latest comments by former Vice-President Atiku Abubakar on petrol subsidy raise a fundamental question: is he seriously proposing an economic policy, or is he simply playing politics with the temporary discomfort Nigerians face? Within a week, Nigerians have heard three different explanations of what an Atiku administration would do about petrol subsidy. The confusion has now become impossible to ignore. First, Atiku’s spokesperson, Paul Ibe, said Atiku would restore petrol subsidy if elected president and later phase it out. Ibe described it as a temporary intervention intended to give Nigerians and businesses room to recover. Then came a clarification from another senior aide, Phrank Shaibu, who said Ibe’s statement was an “unauthorised and misleading characterisation” of Atiku’s position. According to Shaibu, Atiku would not set a predetermined […]
PRESIDENT TINUBU URGES LOCAL GOVERNMENT CHAIRMEN TO PROMOTE INCLUSIVE GOVERNANCE
President Bola Ahmed Tinubu has called on local government chairmen nationwide to make fairness, equal representation and inclusiveness central to their approach to governance. He urged them to ensure that appointments, administrative decisions and the allocation of public resources reflect the diverse interests of the people they serve. The President made the call on Monday in Abuja through the Secretary to the Government of the Federation, Senator George Akume CON, who delivered his keynote address at a workshop organised by the Federal Character Commission for local government chairmen. The workshop focused on practical ways of applying Federal Character principles effectively at the grassroots level. Speaking on the theme, “Translating Federal Character Principles into Local Governance: Bridging Policy and Practice,” Tinubu described Nigeria’s cultural, ethnic and religious diversity as a valuable national asset. He stressed that this diversity must be managed […]
APC party chairman slumps, dies at reconciliation meeting
The All Progressives Congress (APC) in Kogi State has been thrown into mourning following the death of the chairman of its Ijumu Local Government Chapter, Mayowa Solomon Oyewole. Oyewole was said to have slumped and died during a reconciliation meeting among party members at Iyara, the local government headquarters, on Friday. The meeting, convened by a former chairman of the local government, Funsho Olumoko, was said to have been convened to mend fences among warring members and promote unity among the party’s stakeholders in the local government area ahead the 2027 general elections. “Oyewole suddenly collapsed and died midway into the meeting,” a source said. Our correspondent in Kogi reported that he was said to have been immediately rushed to a hospital in Kabba but was pronounced brought in dead by a doctor on duty. Party leaders, stakeholders, members and […]
2027: Storm In Opposition Camp Ahead Consensus-Candidacy
Summit moves by opposition parties to pick a single presidential candidate at their August 31 summit appear to have run into trouble even before the talks take root, Ayemafuge has gathered. Renewed distrust mainly between the camps of the candidate of African Democratic Congress (ADC), Alhaji Atiku Abubakar, and that of the Nigerian Democratic Congress (NDC), Mr. Peter Obi, is said to be fast eroding hope of a united front being championed by proponents of the summit. The summit was originally scheduled for August 18 but was shifted to August 31 following consultations by the six participating political parties and members of the Minority Caucus of the House of Representatives. Their spokesman, Salihu Mohammed Lukman, said the adjustment became necessary in view of the National Peace Summit scheduled for August 18, which was meant to bring together the leadership and […]
Outrage over Atiku’s plan to restore fuel subsidy
Presidential candidate of the African Democratic Congress (ADC) Atiku Abubakar, had promised to reinstate subsidy payment if elected in next year’s presidential election because, according to him, the money made from the removal of fuel subsidy has not been accounted for by the Tinubu administration. President Bola Tinubu, in a response to the allegation, said it smacked of ignorance. But Atiku insisted in a fresh statement yesterday that the federal government got it all wrong on its intervention in the oil sector. The former vice president described his proposal as a “targeted, capped, budgeted, time-bound and independently audited production-support mechanism tied to domestic production and protected against arbitrage.” Experts who bared their minds on the issue in different interviews with our reporters include the Chief Executive Officer, Economic Associates, Dr. Ayo Teriba; Managing Director, Arthur Steven Asset Management, Mr. Olatunde […]
Be the first to leave a comment